Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
(816) 676-1000 St. Joseph, MO

Welcome to Randy Wagers Insurance Agency

St Joseph, Missouri

Google Reviews

Photo of Scott McDowell

Scott McDowell

Great people highly recommended.
Photo of Evan Harnar

Evan Harnar

Excellent Service, Knowledgeable Staff. I have been insured with Benchmark Insurance Agency for several years and have always been very satisfied with their service. They are available, informed, and always willing to answer questions. I highly recommend this agency.
Photo of Claire Schuure

Claire Schuure

I recently requested an insurance quote from this office and I have to say their service is impeccable. They got back to me right away and answered all the questions I had with precision and knowledge. Thanks so much!
Photo of Courtney Hink

Courtney Hink

Thanks BenchMark Insurance for the great quotes on my car insurance and savings! I saved on my car insurance!
Photo of Lane Statz

Lane Statz

Saved $$$ on my car Insurance! Thanks for the big time savings and free quotes on my car insurance!

We are committed to providing clients with the highest quality insurance plans available combined with some of the lowest possible rates. Whether you are shopping for auto insurance, home insurance, life or business insurance, we can help you obtain the best coverage available with the lowest rate possible. 

All of us at Randy Wagers Insurance Agency truly value the long term relationship with our clients, and are proud to give families, individuals and businesses the personal attention required when it matters most. When claims arise, we realize that it can be very stressful and will do everything possible to assure timely and complete recovery.
Allied Insurance
Southern Pioneer

Why choose us?

Competitive Pricing

We work hard to find the best rate through all the carriers we represent.

Local Agent

Having a local agent can help you choose the best body and glass shops, etc.

Multiple Carriers

Representing many carriers means you never have to leave us!

Pay Less

Pay less when you purchase a policy through an independent agent rather than the carrier.